Mon 17th Aug 2026 – A Saucy Tale – A History of Henderson’s Relish – Mark Dawson

Henderson’s Relish started as an obscure Sheffield tradition, and something of a locally held secret.

In more recent years, many well-known people have said they prefer Hendo’s to its more famous rivals – locally born nightclub entrepreneur Peter Stringfellow likes it with his breakfast, and when he comes to Sheffield he takes several bottles of the relish back to London with him. The ‘Arctic Monkeys’ Matt Helders has said: “It is a million times better than Worcestershire Sauce”.

Henry Henderson lived on a farm in Walkeringham, Nottinghamshire, and started as a miller before moving to Sheffield in search of work. In 1874 he married Clara Cornthwaite and they lived in Walkley, but in the 1880s he changed his career, went into partnership with a William Eyre, and became a grocer, selling spices and pickles and ready-made sauces like Yorkshire Relish which sold thousands of bottles annually.

Henderson decided in 1885 that he would make his own sauce because he knew how much the ingredients cost and how much the sauce could be sold for. By 1890 he had moved to 35 Broad Lane, a bigger property nearer the city centre, and needed a girl assistant to fill relish bottles in his shop, showing that the relish was becoming popular. In 1899 he advertised for a shop assistant and gave his contact as Henry Henderson, Sauce Manufacturer.

In 1910 he sold the business to Shaws of Huddersfield, who were established pickle makers, and he retired. George Shaw, now at the helm, moved production to 66 Leavygreave Road in a factory near to the University. He made his son-in-law, Charles Hinksman, manager of Henderson’s Relish

The Shaws needed to get other shops to sell their sauce, so an eye-catching a bright orange label clearly helped – before long they were looking for a printer to make more than a million labels! Company wage books from the1920s show a workforce of around 12 people, headed by Hinksman, who was paid £5 a week. There was a man to help with shifting stock and half a dozen women, who filled bottles, and one or two who worked in the office

In 1937 the ingredients were the same as they are today (except that 75 per cent was vinegar, though that is not the case now) and packaging cost more than the relish. The bottles, produced by a local glass works, cost more than the contents, but the company must have been selling more than a million a year.

In 1958 the company name was changed to Henderson’s (Sheffield) Limited because they wanted to sell other things as well as relish. In the 1960s they reduced the price of the ingredients by diluting the vinegar with 33 per cent water.
They sold fewer bottles, but the bottles cost less to fill so they still made a profit.

In December 1985 they introduced pourers into the bottles, removed prices from the labels, replaced old machinery and increased staff wages and Christmas bonuses.

In 1993, the company dressed up the relish bottles in Sheffield Wednesday and Sheffield United colours for the Cup Semi-finals and persuaded supermarkets to sell their relish. They opened a new factory just off the Parkway in 2013 and claim that the relish is vegan (unlike Lea and Perrins’ Worcestershire Sauce, which contains anchovy paste) and gluten free.

For devotees, there is plenty of reading matter on the market. Books about Henderson’s include “Recipes for Relish” (1998), The “Henderson’s Relish Cookbook” (2014) and “Strong and Northern” (2019).